It’s the most wonderful time of the year: holiday party season. From ugly sweater contests and Secret Santas to Hanukkah parties and Christmas cocktail hours, the months of November and December are full of festivities to enjoy.

Tired of waiting until the last minute and hosting the same white elephant year after year? Mix it up with a Favorite Things Party. Learn what it is, how to host your own, and what party food to plan below. 

How a Favorite Things Party Works

A Favorite Things Party is exactly what it sounds like: a party to celebrate your favorite things. Instead of a traditional gift exchange where people bring one random present for another person, everyone brings multiple copies of their favorite item to share with the group. 

No more exchanging names or fighting over the one actually cool white elephant gift — everyone gets to take home the same exact items. It’s a great way to share joy and maybe even learn something new about your friends and family. 

Here’s what you need to plan your own Favorite Things Party:

  1. Choose a theme. You can host a generic Favorite Things Party or plan it around a specific theme. More on that below! 
  2. Set a budget. Decide how much money each person should spend per item. This will likely depend on how many guests you’re inviting and how generous the group typically is.
  3. Decide how many items each person should bring. The bigger the budget, the fewer items each person brings. Decide if guests are bringing gifts for the whole group, a few people, or one other person. 

Favorite Things Party Themes

While you don’t need a specific theme for your Favorite Things Party, a theme can help narrow options and give guests direction on what to bring. And who doesn’t love a good party pun?

Favorite Sings

Celebrate your favorite album with a music-themed holiday party. Ask each guest to bring copies of their personal album of the year. When it’s their turn to share, they have to sing karaoke to their favorite song from the album.

Favorite Rings

Choose a category — like rings — and leave the rest open to interpretation. Guests can bring an item of their choosing from that category. It could be ring jewelry, ring candy, craft rings, or something related to Lord of the Rings. You get the idea!

Favorite Zings

This theme is perfect for a group of foodies. Each guest brings their favorite spice to cook with and shares with the group. It could be a rare spice they love, an everyday go-to, or a homemade batch of their favorite garlic salt. Whatever makes their mouth water!

Favorite Christmas Cookie

For a less punny but equally delicious theme, host a favorite things cookie exchange. This is a great way to exchange holiday cheer without spending too much money. Ask each guest to bake (or buy) their favorite holiday cookies and bring enough to share with the group. Everyone gets to take home their own holiday cookie box with a variety of desserts to enjoy. 

Favorite Trader Joe’s Item

For another budget-friendly theme, invite guests to bring their must-haves from everyone’s favorite neighborhood grocery store. It could be food, beverages, toiletries, or household goods. Whatever seasonal snacks or timeless treats they stock up on during their TJ’s trips. 

Other fun themes and suggested budgets: 

  • Favorite bottle of wine ($30 – $50)
  • Favorite kitchen tool or cookbook ($20 – $30)
  • Favorite beauty products ($20 – $30)
  • Favorite stocking stuffers ($10 or less)
  • Favorite arts and crafts item ($10 or less)

Combo Holiday Party Formats

For a Favorite Things Party with a twist, try these alternative gift exchange formats. 

Invite guests to a combo white elephant and Favorite Things party. Instead of gag gifts, everyone should bring one copy of their favorite item. Then, ask them to conceal their gift and sneak it into the party so that no one knows who brought which gift ahead of time. As players choose their white elephant gift, they have to guess who brought which item. 

Another fun variation is a Favorite Things party mixed with a slide deck party. Ask each guest to make a short slide deck to explain why they’re obsessed with the item they brought. 

Lastly, channel your inner Maria Von Trapp for the ultimate Blind Date with a Book / Favorite Things Party. Ask guests to bring their favorite books wrapped up in brown paper packaging, tied up with string. Instruct them to write a few clues about the book on the wrapping — the genre, trope, or general theme. Guests can each choose a book (or several, if people brought more than one book) and open it to learn why it’s their friend’s favorite.

Photo by Maxime

What to Serve 

Holiday parties are the perfect excuse to eat, drink, and be merry. Some people prefer a sit-down dinner while others opt for appetizers and drinks.  

A potluck is perfect for a Favorite Things party because it allows guests to bring — you guessed it — their favorite dishes to share. Plus, it takes some of the work off your plate. You can assign each guest an appetizer, side dish, or dessert while you take care of the main course and beverages. 

To have even more fun with it, craft a creative menu with items like “your favorite potato recipe” or “favorite restaurant dish to make at home.” Provide recipe cards so guests can share their favorite recipes in addition to their favorite gift items.

We hope these tips help you discover your new favorite holiday party!

Rachel Kauffman is a Detroit-based content writer, bookworm, and cat mom to two feisty felines.